Tuesday, October 8, 2013

Language Blog




            For my language blog I decided to have a conversation with my mother. The first part was pretty easy. My mom just got a catalog from Swiss Colony and I was pointing out all the things I want for Christmas. Then my mother changed the subject to my upcoming vacation back east over winter break. She could not remember what day my flight is and thought I was taking a red eye flight. I was able to sign to her I leave on the 14th of December but I do not remember what time my flight is at.
            My mother and I had to alter the way we converse to understand each other. I told her before our conversation began that she should keep things simple and ask yes or no questions instead of open ended questions. Since neither of us could remember what time my flight is at, my mom had to go on the computer and look it up. My mother liked the first part of the assignment because she was able to vent out a lot of her frustrations at work and I just nodded in agreement.
            If we were two cultures meeting for the first time I think that the culture that can vocally communicate has the advantage. They do not always have to read body language to know what somebody else is thinking. They just have to listen. It is very difficult to answer an open ended question with just body language. The speaking culture may think that the other culture is not as advanced or smart as them.
            In our society it is very hard for people who cannot hear to have a vocal conversation. Deaf people have developed their own symbolic language so that they can communicate. The only problem is that many people who can speak do not know sign language and it is very difficult to understand each other. I used to work at a restaurant with three deaf people and we had a lot of communication issues. Only one or two other people knew sign language so they had no problems communicating. In order to communicate I had to write down what I wanted to say on a piece of paper and then they would write their answers.
            The second part of the language experiment was very difficult for me. It was very hard for me to not use any part of my body during the conversation. I kept catching myself moving my head up and down when I was agreeing with what my mother had to say. My mom and I were able to communicate better during this part. I was able to ask her what she thought my aunts would like for Christmas from the Swiss Colony catalog. We were able to pick out a nice gift set for them.
            This experiment showed me how important nonverbal signs are in a conversation. We rely on verbal and visual cues to understand what somebody is telling us. There are many people who have problems with nonverbal cues in conversations. People with a mild form of autism called Asperger’s Syndrome cannot read body language which causes a lot of problems. They cannot empathize with others which can make them seem insensitive. They also take things people say literally because they do not understand figurative language. Being able to read body language has many advantages. It allows us to know how a person is feeling and gives us clues when we should or shouldn’t say something. Police are able to tell if a person is lying based on their body language.
             There are a few conditions when it is not beneficial to read body language. People can tell how the president of the United States is feeling based on the body language he displays while giving a speech. This makes lying very hard for politicians to get away with especially if experts are analyzing their body language. Body language can also ruin a job interview. If a person is fidgeting in their seat during an interview, it lets the interviewer know that they are nervous.

4 comments:

  1. I really liked the topic you and your mom picked for the first part of the experiment. I think it was easier because you could just point or thumbs something up. I also agree with you that body language does give you away like when you are lying or nervous.

    ReplyDelete
  2. While I understand that you might want to warn your mom ahead of time what to expect, I do wish you hadn't given her guidance on how to alter her approach ahead of time. Do you think she would have figured this out on her own if you hadn't suggested she simplify her conversation before the experiment started?

    Good discussion on the issue of two opposing cultures.

    How did your mom respond to you in your second experiment? Did you ask her for her impressions or could you detect how she felt about your lack of body language? Often, partners will have a stronger negative reaction to Part B of this experiment so I am curious as to your mom's response.

    Good catch on the issue of Aspergers, though people with autism in general experience this difficulty reading body language.

    You identify situations where it would be good not to EXHIBIT body language, but can you think of any situations where it would be better not to read body language? Hint: Do all cultures use the same body language?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think my mother could have figured out to ask yes or no questions on her own. I asked her to do this because I wanted to keep things simple. She did not listen to my request and asked me a lot of questions about my upcoming trip. During the second part of the assignment my mother asked me what we should get my aunts for Christmas. She paid more attention to the catalog than my facial expressions. I found the second part a lot easier because I was able to ask my mother what she thinks they would want for Christmas.

      Not all cultures use the same body language and signs can have more than one meaning. The thumbs up sign has several different meanings. To some it means okay For divers it means that you are done diving and are going to ascend to the surface. This can cause all kinds of communication errors if body language is misunderstood. So reading body language is not always beneficial because it can send the wrong message.

      Delete