Thursday, August 29, 2013

Darwin's Greatest Influence




Darwin’s Greatest Influence

            I think that Jean-Baptiste Lamarck helped influence and shape Darwin’s work. Lamarck laid down the foundation about evolution and pointed Darwin in the right direction.
            Lamarck is very important because he created the terms biology and invertebrates. Lamarck was a French naturalist who was born in 1744 and died very poor in 1829. For 10 years Lamarck studied invertebrates. He learned about their population numbers, diversity, and how they reproduced. In 1809 he published Philosophie Zoologique, which talks about his theories of evolution. Many scientists like Baffon and Cuvier did not like his theories and did whatever they could to discredit him. Lamarckism refers to his theory that acquired traits can be inherited. He believed that if the environment changes, then organisms have to change. When their behavior is altered it causes a greater or lesser use of an organ or structure. Our textbook uses giraffes as an example to explain his theory.
            Lamarck’s theories fall under a few points of “how does evolution work”. The first is if the environment changes, traits that are helpful or adaptive will be different. Lamarck thought that giraffes have long necks because they had to keep reaching into the trees to get food because all the food was high up in the trees. This caused their necks to experience more use, and as a result it grew longer. Even though this theory is wrong, it helped Darwin discover the right answer. The second point Lamarck’s theories fall under is traits must be inheritable. The giraffes with longer necks were able to eat more food and reproduce more than giraffes with short necks. Lamarck did not realize that populations evolve, not individuals.
            I do not think that Darwin would have made all his theories about evolution and natural selection without Lamarck’s help. Lamarck was the first to connect changes in organisms with the environment. Darwin was able to fix Lamarck’s theory about how giraffes got their long necks. He observed that neck size in the giraffe population varies. Over time food becomes harder to reach because all the lower leaves were eaten. The giraffes with longer necks were able to eat the food higher up in the trees. They passed this trait to their offspring and over time the neck size in giraffes increased.
            During Darwin’s time the church still had a lot of influence over people. The people in England were scared that evolution would rip apart society and cause people to become savages. As a result Darwin was hesitant about publishing his research. He did not want his peers to laugh at him and his theories. Darwin finally got the courage to publish when Alfred Russel Wallace came up with the same ideas. If Darwin did not publish when he did, Wallace probably would have been given credit for Darwin’s discoveries.

Work Cited
            Waggoner, Ben, Brian Speer. “Jean-Baptiste Lamarck (1744-1829)”. University of California Museum of Paleontology. 9 Oct. 1998. Web. 27 Aug. 2013. < http://www.ucmp. berkeley.edu/history/lamarck.html.>.

 






 

7 comments:

  1. Hello,
    upon reading your blog i became very happy to see that you are just as frustrated with this system as i am. In addition to this, i much appreciate that you gave JB Lamarck allot of the credit for the premise of evolution.the statement that "Darwin was able to fix Lamarck's theory" was probably one of the best ways to put it. I think that without the foundation of the theory itself, not many would have taken interest and gone against the church.
    thanks for the information,
    Maria Hernandez

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hello, I wanted to comment on how much I liked your thoughts on how Darwin was able to take Lamarck's theory about giraffes long necks and improve it. While I was doing research for my blog post I also read about this and found a little song that became popular after all the theories about how giraffes got their long necks.I wanted to share it with you because it demonstrates how people took the information and I found the song very funny.


    "A deer with a neck that was
    longer by half
    Than the rest of his family's
    (try not to laugh)
    By stretching
    and stretching
    became a Giraffe
    Which nobody
    can deny"

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you for posting the poem! Do you have a source?

      Delete
  3. Hello Rachel,

    I thought your post was very informative and gives a clear understanding of how Lamarck positively influenced Darwin. I find it to be extremely important that you pointed out the fact that Lamarck’s theory on Giraffe’s helped Darwin to discover a more favorable theory. JB Lamarck was very important due to his attempt to explain the evolutionary process allowing Darwin to build upon it. Overall great post!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Rachel,
    In reading your post i noticed how clearly your understanding of the material is. I love that you included the giraffe comparison to Darwin's theory, it added interest and understanding to the topic. I found your post very interesting as I am a biology major and without Lamarck, biology would not be as we know it today.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Rachel,
    I also agree that Lamarck did not get enough credit that he deserved for helping in Darwin's research. Although Lamarck had the wrong answer it helped Darwin because he could get rid of that possibility and focus on how else evolution could occur. It's sad that he died poor because he really was a brilliant man, he was at least trying to solve the puzzle.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Very good background on Lamarck's work. I also agree with your two selected choices in bullet points, involving the environment and heritability.

    Lamarck wasn't the only scientist to work with the concept of evolutionary theory. Even Darwin's own grandfather, Erasmus, toyed with the idea, but Lamarck was really the first to propose a mechanism, even if it was a faulty one. Darwin certainly built off of Lamarck's work, but I'm not sure if he couldn't have come up with it without Lamarck.

    With regard to the influence of the church, I think the idea that the concept of evolution would rip society apart is overstating it, at least with regard to evolution itself. Any work that went against the teaching of the church (not just evolution) created an rumble in the church and society, just because it was not wise to challenge the church. That said, I agree that Darwin was worried about publishing, but was he only worried about himself or was he also worried about how it might affect his family?

    Other than these (minor) points, good post.

    ReplyDelete